Follow up on Eliot: my comments & questions from the NYTimes

Following on from my earlier related posting, I noticed that the NYTimes did select my Comments & Questions –thanks NYT– so here they are:

“245. March 13th, 2008; 3:36 am

The common wisdom seems to be that Mr. Spitzer was hoist on his own crusading petard. There is a suggestion in the air that if he hadn’t been “such a hypocrite” that this might not have come out the way it did.
Many wellknown figures –among them Alan Dershowitz and David Boies– have raised serious questions, that are not easy to evaluate, about how Mr. Spitzer came to be “singled out” –if indeed he was “singled out”– and seem to be suggesting that the whole story of how this all unfolded has not been told, including questioning as to how the NYT was chosen to be given the story in the first place, and what part his political enemies might have played in outing him.

How confident is the NYT that it knows the whole story?
What part if any did Mr. Spitzer’s enemies play in his outing?
Does the NYT consider in retrospect that it was sufficiently aware of Mr. Spitzer’s astounding immaturity and gave it proper coverage to your readers over the course of his career?
Was the NYT as shocked as the rest of us?

— Posted by Malachi McCormick

Both comments and pings are currently closed. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. 

One Response to “Follow up on Eliot: my comments & questions from the NYTimes”

  1. Kevin T. McEneaney

    Talking Points Memo posted some thingsthat indicate the FBI tried to nail him earlier but failed. Bush has used the FBI like storm troopers. Apparently Spitzer had been seeing prostitues for abut six years and this particular one for two years,since she was twenty. The financial transaction they nailed Spitzer on was one he himself had put into place as a new innovation. The real problem is having a public official subject to possible blackmail, a signature trait of the FBI itself, so he has to go and will probably get disbarred from the practice of law since Spitzer violated a regulation of law that he had put into play. A sorry story.